Preliminary Scores / Pending partner validation · Internal research use only
Jeff Kinney
National Powersport Auctions

Jeff Kinney

VP of Operations

1990
Year Founded
10
Company-Owned Facilities
6,335
Combined Social Following
Parent companyWholly owned subsidiary of Copart, Inc. (Nasdaq: CPRT)
HeadquartersPoway, California
The 7 on 7+ Assessment

7 on 7+ Score

Website Score
22 / 49
Website effectiveness as evidence of leadership thinking. Seven criteria, each scored 1 to 7. Built on methodology developed by Alan Power and Gair Maxwell.
IDEA Score
23 / 49
Power of your complete digital presence, including social, search, gen-AI - to generate PULL.
Website Score
22
Tracks your website effectiveness.
+
IDEA Adjustment
3
Adjusts for your complete digital footprint.
=
7 on 7+ Score
25
Your legend-building signal.
Category Leader
IAA Rec Rides
16
Website
23
IDEA
IAA Rec Rides trades on a trademarked auction line and a state-by-state buyer gate that NPA's own site does not yet have an equivalent for, though NPA's website still scores higher overall, 22 to IAA's 16, since Rec Rides remains one line inside a larger network rather than a dedicated home. Off-site, the two now score identically, 23 to 23: IAA's scale outsizes NPA by an order of magnitude on every channel, yet neither company's content addresses powersports specifically, and NPA reaches the same number through two executives on camera rather than raw reach.

Executive Takeaway

National Powersport Auctions scores 22 out of 49 on its website and 23 out of 49 on its off-site signal, for a combined 25. The site already beats every competitor on its own terms, mostly because Manheim and IAA run powersports as one line inside a larger network rather than as a dedicated home, and a sixty-person leadership roster, Chairman Cliff Clifford and CEO Jim Woodruff included, sits on the site's own team page with real photographs and titles but no personal stories or video attached. Off-site, NPA's signal now matches IAA's own, twenty-three to twenty-three, though the two arrive there by different routes: IAA's near-40,000-follower LinkedIn and 227,000-follower Facebook carry two real content pillars with no leader ever appearing in either, while NPA's much smaller channels carry two executives, Tony Altieri and Mike Murray, on camera, plus Synchrony's 2026 Strategic Excellence Award. Neither company's off-site voice speaks to powersports specifically. What is missing for NPA is not activity, it is a single story tying the Value Guide, the sixty-person team, and the growing video series into one answer for who NPA is.

Website Score — By Criterion

Seven criteria, each scored 1 to 7 by Alan Power and Gair Maxwell. The sum is your website score out of 49. Vistage room average: 13 to 14. A score above 20 is genuinely strong.

3
First Impression
Immediate 2-3 sec WOW factor. Instant clarity on who this brand speaks to.
The homepage leads with "Ride with the leader in pre-owned powersports," a claim any auction company in the category could make. The auction calendar and category navigation are clear, but nothing on arrival signals what makes NPA different from a Manheim or an IAA.
1
Impact
Signature homepage video. Genuine human connection, cinematic and story-based.
No signature film, the cinematic, story-driven homepage video the top band calls for, plays anywhere on the site. There is no video of any kind on the homepage. The auction calendar and inventory photography carry the page instead.
4
Originality
Highly distinctive identity. Instantly recognizable. Not a template.
NPA Value Guide, a trademarked wholesale valuation tool, sits in the top navigation alongside VIN Decode and a Digital Ad Package. These tools are real distinguishers, sitting inside an otherwise standard auction site structure of buy, sell, search, and category tiles.
3
Culture
Video evidence from real people indicating a destination employer. Not a values list.
A Meet Our Team page lists more than sixty people across five tiers, from Chairman Cliff Clifford and CEO Jim Woodruff down to territory sales managers, each shown with a real photograph and a title. No video and no personal stories accompany any of them, and the one culture statement on the site, "Founded by dealers, for dealers," stays a single paragraph.
3
Consistency
Track record of publishing current, original content across platforms.
A monthly market report exists and was current as of August, but it lives off a social link rather than an on-site archive, and no blog or news index with dates was found on the site itself.
4
Audience Reach
Numbers indicating a growing community. Evidence of genuine engagement.
Three separate portals, for lenders, transportation, and brokers, each with its own login, sit alongside six vehicle categories. No testimonials appear anywhere, and the only capture mechanism is a text-reminder opt-in, not a subscribe or newsletter offer.
4
Visuals
Cohesive visual elements reflecting brand spirit. Distinctive design language.
Inventory photography is custom, shot at the company's own auction sites. The NPA wordmark in black and red stays consistent across the site, though it functions as a standard lockup rather than a distinctive mark.
IDEA Score — The Signal Before the Click

How You Show Up in the World

The IDEA Score measures what happens before someone reaches your website, the off-site signal that shapes perception from the first search, the LinkedIn scroll, the founder post.

23
out of 49
IDEA Score — Digital Footprint

The Idea That Changes Everything

Seven axes. Each one measures a different dimension of how your off-site signal lands, not what your website says, but what the world hears before anyone clicks.

Pull vs. push. Category of one vs. category of many. A founder voice vs. a corporate signal. These are the levers that determine whether a prospect arrives already interested, or arrives already skeptical.

4
Pull vs. Push
Content creates gravity vs. broadcast/promotional
The feed splits close to evenly between routine announcements and real story content that is outperforming them. A native market report post carries real data, and a five-part leader-video series grew from 16 reactions to 62 over two months, both earning more attention than the auction-promo and event posts sitting alongside them.
2
ONLY vs. Category
Proprietary language/named POV vs. sounds like every competitor
Off-site language repeats the "leader in pre-owned powersports" claim and "nation's largest provider," phrasing any large auction competitor could use. NPA Value Guide, the one real asset in the mix, appears only inside a fifteen-item specialties list rather than as an argument anywhere in the feed.
3
Audience Building
Clear who it's for AND building following beyond buyers
Every touchpoint, a client meeting that hosted more than sixty lenders, a recurring dealer-appreciation series, a trade-conference appearance, reaches people already inside NPA's dealer and lender network. No newsletter or subscribe mechanism exists to bring in anyone new, and follower counts across all four channels remain in the low thousands or under.
4
Different-er vs. Better
Competes on distinctiveness/belief vs. features/specs/price
An industry award and a "nation's largest provider" claim still lead the self-description, but two pieces break from credentials into an actual stated position: calling itself "more than an auction, a powersport remarketing partner," and a video series built around "the strength of its team," the single highest-engagement post found.
3
IDEA vs. Best Practices
Organizing belief visible across all channels vs. channel-by-channel
The leader-video series posts identically to LinkedIn, Instagram, and YouTube in the same week, while Facebook runs its own disconnected event promotions. A native market report and a recurring dealer-prize series exist alongside it, but nothing ties the three formats together under one stated story.
4
Founder/Leader Voice
Named human with consistent opinionated first-person presence
Tony Altieri, VP of Business Development, narrates a five-part video series in first person, and Mike Murray, VP of Dealer Services, fronts his own webinar independently of that series. Both post from the corporate page rather than a personal profile, which is what keeps this short of a leader speaking in their own words from their own account.
3
Cultural Relevance
Signal connects to a larger shift in the world vs. exists in isolation
Synchrony naming NPA the winner of its 2026 Strategic Excellence Award, and a confirmed presenting role at NPDA DealerConnect, are the two moments that reach outside NPA's own news. Both still read as company achievements rather than genuine participation in an outside conversation, and no speaking or media-commentary record exists beyond them.
Digital Footprint Scan

Where You're Showing Up, and Where You're Not

LinkedIn
Active
About 2,900 followers. A five-part leader-video series featuring Tony Altieri and Mike Murray grew from 16 to 62 reactions over two months, a native market report post carries real data, and a client event and Synchrony's 2026 Strategic Excellence Award both drew the highest engagement in the sample, 96 and 54 reactions.
Instagram
Active
2,800 followers across 1,303 posts. Organized into Auctions, NPA Crew, NPA Dealer, and Races highlights, with the same leader-video series cross-posted here.
YouTube
Active
613 subscribers and 64 videos, with new uploads roughly weekly. The most-viewed evergreen video has drawn 2,396 views over three years.
Facebook
Weak
85 followers on a page that reads as newly stood up, running event-day posts with little independent following yet.
Strategic Opportunity

How to Build Your Legend

Short Term

Answer the BHOQ before building anything else
Nothing on the site or in the social feed states who NPA is beyond a scale claim. The Value Guide, a sixty-person leadership roster, and the Altieri and Murray video appearances are all fragments of an answer to who NPA is beyond the auction house that have not been assembled into one signature story.
Decide who leads the story next
The video series already spans five installments across three channels, and Mike Murray now fronts his own webinar alongside Tony Altieri. The open decision is whether either becomes the person who publishes in his own words from his own profile, rather than staying a voice the company posts about.
Decide what the leadership roster is for
Sixty-plus leaders and managers, from the Chairman to territory sales, already carry real photographs, titles, and facility ties on a page most visitors will never find. What is undecided is what that roster is for: an org chart, or proof of the dealer-first culture the site claims in one line. That is a decision for leadership to settle, not a page-design task.

Medium Term

Give the BHOQ answer an Iconic Identity
Once leadership settles who NPA is beyond a scale claim, that answer needs a positioning line, a message hierarchy, and a visual system built around it, not just a homepage edit. The Value Guide and the founded-by-dealers history are the raw material; an Iconic Identity turns them into language and design the whole company uses the same way, everywhere.
Turn the market report into Brand-Driven Growth
The report already earns real engagement natively on LinkedIn. Brand-Driven Growth work builds it into a campaign platform, a recurring, owned piece of growth architecture that drives demand on its own schedule, rather than a report that happens to get posted.
Build NPA's Media Company around Altieri and Murray
Five video installments and two executives are already proving the model. Becoming a Media Company turns that proof into an owned engine, content published on a real cadence across every channel, including Facebook, that compounds into an audience NPA does not have to keep buying.
Competitive Landscape

Who's in the Conversation

Manheim Specialty Auctions
Multi-vertical auction network (Cox Automotive)
One of 21 branded auction lines inside Manheim's broader network, covering boats, RVs, motorcycles, and trucks from a single shared page. No video, no team content, and no dated publishing were found on the page.
IAA Rec Rides
Powersports auction division (RB Global)
A trademarked, dedicated powersports auction line with a state-by-state buyer-eligibility gate and vehicle-type search. IAA's corporate LinkedIn carries nearly 40,000 followers, though its content runs corporate and operational rather than powersports-specific.
CrankyApe.com
Independent powersports, RV, and marine auction site
A long-running, independently operated auction site built on dated technology, with category-tile navigation and no team, video, or dated editorial content found anywhere on the page.
National Powersport Auctions
Where NPA actually leads
NPA's own site outscores all three competitors on the website half, largely because none of the three operates a dedicated, single-category home of its own: two are product lines inside larger auction networks, and the third runs on aging technology. Off-site, NPA and IAA now score identically, twenty-three each, by different routes: IAA's scale, nearly 40,000 LinkedIn followers and 227,000 on Facebook, carries two real content pillars with no leader ever appearing in either, while NPA's much smaller channels carry two executives, Tony Altieri and Mike Murray, on camera, plus Synchrony's 2026 Strategic Excellence Award. Neither company's off-site voice speaks to powersports specifically.
Market Context

The Industry Around You

Powersports remarketing sits inside a global market approaching $42 billion, with North America still the largest single region. Growth is real, but it is uneven across categories, and the wholesale side of the business is exposed to the same rate and consumer-sentiment swings that show up every month in NPA's own market report.

$41.74B
Global powersports market, 2025
Fortune Business Insights, 2026
$66.84B
Projected global market by 2034
Fortune Business Insights, 2026
46.06%
North America share of 2025 sales
Mordor Intelligence, 2026
6.49%
Projected CAGR, 2026 to 2031
Mordor Intelligence, 2026

What Keeps You Up at Night

The forces shaping National Powersport Auctions's competitive environment, and why standing still is not an option.

📉
Consumer sentiment reversal

NPA's own August 2026 market report recorded consumer sentiment falling 5.3% in a single month and sitting 11.2% below the prior year, with gasoline prices climbing back over $4 a gallon.

Headwind
💳
Financing costs stay elevated

The Federal Reserve has held its range at 3.50% to 3.75% with sentiment shifting toward a hike, keeping floorplan and buyer financing more expensive than dealers saw in earlier cycles.

Headwind
🏬
A crowded wholesale channel

Manheim and IAA both operate powersports auction lines backed by larger public parent companies, and independent operators like CrankyApe compete for the same dealer consignment volume NPA depends on.

Headwind

Where the Opportunity Lives

The same forces creating pressure are also creating openings for those willing to lead.

📈
A market still growing

The global powersports market is projected to grow from roughly $41.74 billion in 2025 to $66.84 billion by 2034.

Fortune Business Insights, 2026 Tailwind
🇺🇸
North America leads the category

North America accounted for 46.06% of global powersports sales in 2025, the largest share of any region and the market NPA's ten facilities already serve.

Mordor Intelligence, 2026 Tailwind
🎤
A leadership voice already gaining traction

A five-part video series featuring VP of Business Development Tony Altieri grew from 16 reactions to 62 over two months, and a 2026 Strategic Excellence Award from Synchrony gives NPA a real piece of third-party recognition to build the next chapter around.

Tailwind
🔒
Unlock Your Full Roadmap

Your Future-State Brand Expression

The moves above address what a leadership team can decide and build now. The full roadmap sequences Clarify, Identity, and Growth into a single plan for turning a sixty-person team and a growing video series into one signature story dealers, lenders, and manufacturers recognize on sight.

Phase 1
Clarify
Settle who leads the story next, Altieri or Murray, and answer the BHOQ in one sentence leadership can repeat.
Phase 2
Identity
Rebuild the homepage around that answer, move the market report onto a dated, on-site archive, and give the sixty-person team page the personal stories and video it is still missing.
Phase 3
Growth
Turn the leader-video series into a running media engine across all four channels and close the gap between the website score and the off-site signal.
Schedule a Call